Certifying Sober Living: Ten Years of State Records on the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH)
Observed data
This report computes nothing beyond counts and sums of figures stated in the records themselves. Every statement is tied to a page in a named production, filing or document, and the notes give that page. Grievance totals add the quarterly figures MASH reported to BSAS, as MASH reported them. Dollar figures are the maximum obligations written in executed contracts, not amounts paid.
State records on the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing: two corrective action plans, a 2018 compliance review, 477 grievances and the contracts.
Cite This Report
Full citation
Vanderburgh Foundation. 2026. Certifying Sober Living: Ten Years of State Records on the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH). Vanderburgh Foundation. https://www.vanderburghhouse.com/research/mash-certification-records/
Attribution line
Vanderburgh Foundation, "Certifying Sober Living: Ten Years of State Records on the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH)" (2026), CC BY 4.0, https://www.vanderburghhouse.com/research/mash-certification-records/
This data is published under CC BY 4.0. You may reuse it, including commercially, provided you credit Vanderburgh Foundation and link back to this page.
The Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH) is the nonprofit the Department of Public Health pays to certify sober homes in Massachusetts.1 State records produced under the Public Records Law show that the Bureau of Substance Addiction Services documented serious performance problems at MASH in 2017, 2018, 2020 and 2023, and put MASH on corrective action plans.2
Summary of findings
- Three homes for which city building or fire officials reported fire-safety and building permit problems in 2024 and 2025, at 28 High Street in Greenfield, 3 Smiths Lane in Kingston and 103 Euclid Avenue in Springfield, were still listed as MASH-certified on November 14, 2026. For one, MASH’s grievance investigator wrote that it would “conduct a complete investigation”; no outcome is on file.3
- Since October 2025 MASH has told applicants in writing that it will not certify homes affiliated with Vanderburgh House or Hunter Foote.4 In one 2026 decertification notice, MASH told the operator the decision was not based on the operation of the homes.5
- In 2018 the Bureau of Substance Addiction Services (BSAS) wrote that it had met with MASH “without success over months” about ongoing performance issues.6
- A 2018 BSAS compliance review recorded that MASH lost most of its certification applications, listed homes as certified that had not been inspected, and certified facilities that were not sober homes.7
- BSAS issued MASH a second corrective action plan on February 1, 2023, after a grievance about a MASH training, and found that every member of MASH’s Ethics Committee was a sober home owner.8
- MASH’s own quarterly reports to BSAS record 477 grievances in the 14 quarters from July 2021 to March 2025 for which reports were produced.9
- The statute calls for complaint rules, but the records contain no process for deciding a grievance about MASH itself. BSAS’s internal reviews of three such grievances record no finding and no decision sent to the person who filed them.10
Where these records come from
This report rests on three productions DPH made to the Vanderburgh Foundation under the Massachusetts Public Records Law, on request numbers BSAS-2024-62 and BSAS-2025-35.11 DPH produced a 275-page set of MASH reports and 171 MASH report spreadsheets on February 14, 2025, a 65-page set of meeting notes and agendas on March 5, 2025, and a 234-page contract set on March 21, 2025.12 On request BSAS-2025-35, DPH produced a 161-page contract and policy binder on July 25, 2025, and a 354-page set of emails on May 22, 2026.13
Every page was read, and each statement in this report is tied to a page in those productions or in the other documents listed in the exhibit library. Page numbers in the citations are PDF page numbers of the production named.
How certification is supposed to work
Massachusetts law gives sober home certification to BSAS, a bureau of the Department of Public Health, under M.G.L. c. 17, s. 18A.14 The statute says BSAS lists a residence after reviewing three items: proof the operator completed training, a deed or lease showing the operator owns or rents the property, and a municipal certificate showing no tax liens.14 The statute also requires DPH, with BSAS, to adopt rules that set a process for receiving complaints and criteria for removing a residence from the certified list.15
Certification is voluntary on paper, but state agencies and statewide treatment vendors may not refer anyone to a sober home that is not certified.16 In practice BSAS does not certify homes itself.17 A 2023 state fact sheet says BSAS oversees certification through contracts with MASH and a second nonprofit, the Recovery Homes Collaborative (RHC), which inspects homes and investigates grievances.17
How MASH got the contract
DPH’s 2014 procurement for a certifying vendor stated that the Commonwealth would use the standards of the National Alliance for Recovery Residences (NARR) as the sole basis for certification.18 DPH’s bid summary and its written answers to bidders described the vendor as a member-directed nonprofit that is “not a provider of sober home services,” and DPH’s written answers to bidders said individual members of the vendor could own sober homes.19 In 2015 DPH amended the procurement, citing the sole applicant’s response, and split the work between two vendors.20
The Gavin Foundation held the certification contract at first.21 On May 2, 2017, BSAS asked DPH’s chief financial officer for a waiver of normal procurement rules to move the certification contract from the Gavin Foundation to MASH, effective July 1, 2017.21 The waiver memo quoted MASH’s own 2014 application as saying MASH did not yet have the membership or infrastructure to lead a statewide effort.22
MASH’s registry listed 188 certified homes with 3,046 beds on November 14, 2026.23

The money
DPH pays MASH under two contracts, one for certification and one for rental assistance.25 The figures below are the maximum obligations written in the executed contracts.
| Contract | Period | Maximum obligation | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Certification (renewal) | FY2018 to FY2023 | $1,260,000 ($210,000 a year) | Exhibit 6 |
| Certification | FY2024 to FY2028 | $1,342,220 | Exhibit 12 |
| Sober Home Rental Assistance | FY2024 to FY2026 | $2,878,127, amended to $3,891,962 | Exhibit 11 |
Sources26
Under the rental assistance contract, MASH grants up to $3,000 or 100 days of rent or deposit to tenants of certified sober homes.27 DPH’s notices to MASH list federal Recovery Housing Program money, a HUD program, as a funding source for that contract.28 MASH’s federal tax returns report total revenue of $188,199 for fiscal year 2018 and $745,225 for fiscal year 2025.29 The Recovery Homes Collaborative holds its own contract with a maximum of $1,250,000 for fiscal years 2024 to 2028, and lists the Gavin Foundation as a $250,000 subcontractor for inspections and grievances.30
A decade of documented problems
The records show BSAS raising the same kinds of problems with MASH in 2017, 2018, 2020 and 2023.32
2017: reports BSAS could not rely on
MASH’s February 27, 2017 weekly report left the count of decertified homes blank because, it said, its system could not generate the figure.33 An October 2017 BSAS agenda listed MASH website data with the note “garbage in, garbage out.”34 MASH’s report for July to September 2017 said 33 of 52 homes due for recertification had not been recertified.35
Notes of a November 2, 2017 meeting record BSAS concerns that MASH’s management system did not show actual inspection counts.36 On December 19, 2017, BSAS staff told MASH it had not submitted an accurate weekly report in at least six months.37 The same notes record that MASH applied for and received a federal SAMHSA grant without telling BSAS during the application.37
2018: the compliance review
On March 20, 2018, BSAS gave MASH a written contract compliance review and a memo listing its concerns.38 The memo said BSAS had met with MASH “without success over months” in regular and ad hoc meetings about ongoing performance problems.6 The review recorded these problems, among others:
- MASH itself reported that most of its certification applications were lost or missing.39
- MASH certified homes that had not been inspected and listed them on its website, and removed them only after BSAS raised it on October 30, 2017.40
- MASH certified facilities that were not sober homes, including BSAS-funded case management and treatment programs.41
- Operators complained that MASH lost their documents and told them they would be decertified when they asked why they had to resubmit, and MASH’s executive director told BSAS that letters to those homes were not necessary.42
- MASH staff said they did not have accurate certification dates for homes and did not contact operators to get them.39
- Several homes reported never receiving a certificate.43
- Twenty-three homes were overdue for recertification in the second quarter of fiscal 2018, fourteen of them by more than 30 days.42
- MASH did not always tell BSAS promptly when it decertified a home or why.44
- MASH held no continuing education training for certified homes, and BSAS had to organize a NARR training for trainers on MASH’s behalf.45
- MASH’s Sober Housing 101 training needed heavy revision for every session from February 2017 to February 2018 and was at times “unprofessional, inappropriate for the setting” or negative about treatment.46
- The state Substance Abuse Helpline called MASH 5 to 10 times and emailed 6 times about sober home listings without a response.47
- MASH staff repeatedly removed home addresses from its public website, against the contract and BSAS’s instructions.48
- MASH’s weekly report was wrong so often that RHC began producing a parallel report so BSAS would have accurate figures.49
- MASH’s invoices were habitually incorrect, and MASH needed an emergency payment from BSAS to avoid laying off staff, telling BSAS a week before the planned layoffs.50
- MASH reported 5 new certifications and 10 decertifications in one quarter, yet its count of certified homes did not fall.51
The memo also recorded a MASH board member’s report that the board saw the BSAS contract as “burdensome.”6 BSAS set April 2, 2018 as the deadline for a corrective action plan, and wrote that if the problems were not resolved it would convene stakeholders to discuss continuing the certification program.6 MASH’s corrective action plan update of May 31, 2018 promised accurate invoices, accurate weekly and quarterly reports, faster responses to BSAS, and monthly meetings “in a professional, respectful manner.”52
The same update said Ethics Committee grievance findings would be entered into MASH board minutes.53 A later BSAS agenda for a meeting with the MASH board, which is undated, says the corrective action plan was “how we bring MASH back on track with the contract,” that some items were still not done, and that MASH’s prior-year work plan was not executed.54 That agenda also lists MASH billing BSAS for non-contract spending, quarterly reports filed for the wrong period or with math errors, and paper and digital files that did not match.55 In May and June 2018, DPH renewed MASH’s certification contract through fiscal 2023 at $210,000 a year.56
2019 to 2021: staffing and training strain
MASH’s weekly reports show cumulative decertifications rising from 29 at the end of 2018 to 52 by December 2019.57 In December 2020 MASH told BSAS it had trouble recertifying 183 homes a year with its staff, and that adopting NARR’s updated standards would be “very challenging” with its workload.58 At a February 2021 meeting, attendees asked whether certification should be brought into DPH.59 In 2021 MASH’s website grievance page said verbal grievances would not be acted upon, while MASH’s contract and its later bid told DPH that grievances could be made by phone.60
2023: a second corrective action plan
On February 1, 2023, BSAS issued MASH a corrective action plan after a January 19, 2023 grievance about a MASH Sober Housing 101 training.61 BSAS recorded that the grievance alleged stigmatizing language and advice on getting around fair housing protections for people on medication for addiction treatment (MAT).62 BSAS wrote that such language and “loopholes” continued after BSAS first raised them with MASH in fall 2020, and that it had received complaints over two and a half years about an anti-MAT culture among MASH members.63
BSAS found two contract duties not performed satisfactorily: training for new trainers, requested in 2021 and again in August 2022, and a fair and equitable grievance procedure.64 On the grievance procedure, BSAS found that all three members of MASH’s Ethics Committee were sober home owners and only one was a board member, contrary to MASH’s bylaws.63 BSAS recommended adding a provider of medication for addiction treatment to MASH’s board and Ethics Committee.65
MASH responded by making the full board its Ethics Committee, and reported that one board member was a sober home owner.66 DPH awarded MASH the new certification contract on June 23, 2023, through June 30, 2028, with renewal options to 2032.67
2023 to 2025: reports that do not add up
MASH’s quarterly reports to BSAS contradict themselves in several quarters.68 Its report for October to December 2024 gave the dates of the previous quarter in its narrative and said there were no suspensions, while its table showed 2 suspensions and 11 decertifications.69 Its report for July to September 2024 put 17 homes in the application stage in its table and 7 in its narrative.70
MASH said it ended September 30, 2023 with 191 certified homes, and its next report began October 1, 2023 with 188.71 DPH did not produce any MASH quarterly report for October to December 2022, or for most of 2019 through September 2021.72
Grievances: volume and outcomes
MASH reported 477 grievances to BSAS across the 14 quarters from July 2021 to March 2025 for which DPH produced reports, a range of 16 to 55 a quarter.73 Few led to suspension or decertification as MASH reported them.74 In July to September 2024, MASH reported 37 grievances, 9 substantiated, and none leading to suspension or decertification.75
In the same quarter it handled several substantiated grievances through a conversation between the Ethics Committee chair and the operator, including one about a resident’s removal.76 MASH told DPH in 2023 that it keeps grievances about uncertified homes on file but does not investigate them.77 MASH also told DPH that RHC decides whether a grievance is substantiated, while MASH’s written policies give that decision to its Ethics Committee.78 The earliest count in the records is from BSAS: 23 grievances about certified homes in the first half of fiscal 2018, with 12 still open on February 20, 2018.79
When the grievance is about MASH
The statute requires DPH, with BSAS, to adopt rules that set a process for receiving complaints.15 The records produced contain no such process for a grievance about MASH itself, so BSAS has no set procedure for deciding one.80 The reviews described below show what that gap produces. Vanderburgh House, an operator affiliated with the Vanderburgh Foundation, filed four grievances about MASH with BSAS between December 2024 and June 2025.81 In its March 8 grievance Vanderburgh stated that DPH had not acknowledged the first one.82
DPH’s files hold BSAS’s internal reviews of the first three.83 Those reviews list each concern followed by a response drawn mostly from MASH’s executive director or MASH’s reports, and state no BSAS finding and no decision sent to the grievant.83 One review records that “all communication related to VSL homes is currently communicated through MASH’s attorney,” and that BSAS was not privy to those communications.84
Another states that the records reviewed showed one operator complaint, handled through technical assistance and a corrective action plan.85 Vanderburgh’s June 6, 2025 grievance said it had received no response to any of the first three.86 Recovery Housing Initiative, an operator led by Shane Thomas, filed its own grievance about MASH with BSAS on May 25, 2026, and no response to it is on file.87
What NARR said
MASH is NARR’s Massachusetts affiliate, and Vanderburgh Sober Living also took its concerns to NARR.88 On May 28, 2025, NARR’s vice president wrote that NARR’s board had reviewed the grievance and recommended that MASH either set a reasonable timeframe to resume certification reviews of VSL homes or give VSL and NARR specific evidence that those homes fail NARR’s standards.88 MASH’s executive director replied the same day that “the pause in certification applies only to certifying new homes.”89
NARR answered the next day that its recommendation applied to all homes operated by VSL.90 MASH forwarded the exchange to BSAS, and BSAS’s acting assistant director asked to discuss it the next day.91 Two weeks earlier MASH had told BSAS it was rewriting its grievance policy because of grievances an operator had filed, and asked BSAS how to interpret the word “operator.”92
Grievances about homes that stayed certified
In March 2025, grievances submitted through MASH’s website form reported fire-safety and building permit problems at certified homes in Greenfield, Kingston and Springfield.93 The strongest of those grievances rested on letters and emails from city building and fire officials. Those records are summarized below, with what MASH or its investigator said in response and what MASH’s public registry showed on November 14, 2026.
Greenfield
On November 21, 2024, Greenfield’s Building Commissioner sent the owner of 28 High Street, a MASH-certified home then operating as Grace Space, a Notice of Violation of the state building code. The letter records that the operator described the home as MASH-certified, and that 17 people were living there when a porch fire broke out on October 7, 2024.94 It found that the building had been converted to residential use without permits or a certificate of occupancy, cited the owner for “failing to provide the required fire protection/fire detection systems,” and warned that a cease and desist order could follow.95
On February 25, 2025, the commissioner wrote that the owners “have not complied” with the notice.96 A grievance attaching both documents was filed through MASH’s website on March 15, 2025. Two days later the Recovery Homes Collaborative, MASH’s grievance investigation partner, replied: “We will conduct a complete investigation.”97 No finding or outcome is on file.
When BSAS later reviewed Vanderburgh’s March 31, 2025 grievance about MASH, which raised this home, it recorded MASH’s position that “land use and zoning is not within their purview.”98 The Greenfield notice was issued under the state building code and cited missing fire protection and fire detection systems.95 In October 2025, by contrast, MASH’s counsel suspended five Vanderburgh House homes indefinitely over website advertising and service marks.99 On November 14, 2026, MASH’s registry listed 28 High Street as certified for 23 beds under a new name, Whole Heart Greenfield.100
Kingston
On March 27, 2025, Kingston’s Deputy Fire Chief wrote that the department “has no record of either a fire alarm or sprinkler system” at 3 Smiths Lane, a MASH-certified home. He added that a building used as a group home would need “at the very least, a fire alarm system.”101 A grievance stating that 14 people lived in the home was prepared on MASH’s form the next day. The copy on file is a screenshot of the completed form, and no MASH acknowledgment is on file. MASH’s registry listed the home, now called All Roads Recovery – Smiths Lane, as certified for 23 beds in July 2026 and again on November 14, 2026.102
Springfield
On March 20 and 21, 2025, Springfield’s Deputy Building Commissioner wrote that the city had “no record of any permits to change the use to group residence” for two certified homes, 103 Euclid Avenue and 58 Howes Street. He wrote that 103 Euclid Avenue’s 2,458 square feet of living space allowed at most 12 persons.103
Grievances on both homes were prepared on MASH’s form on March 22, 2025, and no MASH acknowledgment is on file. On November 14, 2026, MASH’s registry listed 103 Euclid Avenue, which the city said could hold 12 persons, as certified for 20 beds under the name Recovery House, operated by We Do Recover. 58 Howes Street was no longer listed.104
The city records do not show whether the operators have since installed fire protection or obtained permits, or whether MASH’s investigator visited any of these homes. Each home’s current listing can be checked on the MASH certified residences list.
The affiliation rule, in MASH’s words
The examples in this section involve Vanderburgh-related homes, and Vanderburgh House is suing MASH over them (see About this report).105 They are reported here in MASH’s own written words. In November 2024 the MASH board voted to pause new certification applications from Vanderburgh House, Hunter Foote and VSL chartered operators.106
MASH’s stated reasons for that pause are among the matters before the court in the pending lawsuit.107 In its first grievance to BSAS, Vanderburgh alleged that MASH issued no formal notice that any home violated a MASH standard.108 According to a Vanderburgh letter to NARR, MASH’s executive director replied in December 2024 that MASH is not subject to the Open Meeting Law, and MASH did not release the minutes of the meeting.109
No MASH board or Ethics Committee minutes appear in either DPH production, although the request asked for them.110 On October 6, 2025, MASH’s counsel suspended five Vanderburgh House homes indefinitely, citing MASH Standard 2.e on advertising and service marks, until the Vanderburgh website and promotional materials met MASH’s terms.99 The letter said MASH would decide “in its sole discretion” when its requests had been met.99
The same day, MASH told a new operator at a Brockton home that MASH was “currently not certifying any properties that are affiliated with Dr. Hunter Foote.”105 Since then MASH has stated the rule to other applicants:
| Date | To | MASH wrote |
|---|---|---|
| October 13, 2025 | Recovery Housing Initiative (Shane Thomas), Lowell | “any home affiliated with Vanderburgh House does not qualify for certification” |
| May 1, 2026 | An applicant | the home “does not qualify for certification at this time,” citing possible affiliation |
| June 22, 2026 | Another applicant | MASH is not accepting applications from homes “owned, operated, managed” by or affiliated with Vanderburgh entities |
| August 5, 2026 | A property owner | no applications where the property or business is affiliated with, or “financially benefits,” Vanderburgh entities |
| August 7, 2026 | An operator of three homes | three homes to be decertified after their ownership changed; a trust tied to the Vanderburgh Foundation was “ineligible as the property owner” |
| September 8, 2026 | Brittney Alvarado, 16 Germain Street, Worcester | “MASH is not certifying sober homes that show an affiliation with Vanderburgh House” |
Sources111
In its August 7, 2026 email, MASH told the operator the decision was not based on the operation of the homes.5 None of the three items the statute names for listing a residence (proof that the operator completed training, a deed or lease, and a municipal certificate showing no tax liens) concerns who a home is affiliated with.14
What DPH told the Legislature in 2025
In July 2025, DPH sent the Legislature a study of sober homes ordered by Chapter 285 of the Acts of 2024. It counted 200 MASH-certified homes with 3,129 beds, and said BSAS’s $500,000 annual appropriation for certification and oversight has not changed since 2016.112 It described MASH’s grievance process but reported no grievance counts or outcomes, and it did not mention the 2018 compliance review or either corrective action plan.113
At DPH’s April 2025 listening session, one participant said they had reported overcrowding, life safety violations and structural problems at two certified homes, received no response, and that “both homes remain certified.”114 Others suggested revisiting MASH’s board structure to avoid perceived conflicts of interest from sober home owners serving on it.114 DPH recommended more funding and closer work with cities and towns, and made no recommendation about how grievances are handled.115 What the report says, and leaves out, is covered in a separate article.
What would fix this
BSAS staff identified many of the problems in this report and raised them with MASH, in some cases for years. The means to resolve them sit with DPH. Four steps would address what the records show:
- Rebid the certification contract when its current term ends on June 30, 2028, rather than renewing it to 2032, and weigh the vendor’s performance record in the award.67
- Adopt the complaint rules the statute requires, including a process for deciding grievances about the certifying vendor itself, with a written decision sent to the person who filed.15
- Publish grievance counts and outcomes each quarter, by home, so residents, operators and referral sources can see how grievances are resolved.
- Require that every certification decision rest on the statute and the NARR standards the Commonwealth adopted, and that any denial, suspension or decertification state the standard the home failed.18
What the records do not show
DPH has not produced records of MASH’s October 2025 suspensions, any MASH board minutes, or MASH grievance counts for 2018 through mid-2021.116 A broader request, BSAS-2026-42, is pending after DPH said one search would return about 175,000 pages and asked that it be narrowed.117 BSAS’s own 2025 review of the Vanderburgh grievances is not dated and was never sent to the grievant as far as the record shows.118 MASH’s grievance files and its investigator’s reports on the March 2025 grievances about certified homes are not in hand. For the Kingston and Springfield grievances the only copies on file are screenshots of the completed MASH forms, so receipt by MASH is not proven.119
Exhibit library
- Exhibit 1. BSAS Request for Response 506123: Voluntary Statewide Certification for Alcohol and Drug Free Housing, with DPH questions and answers November 14, 2014. PDF.
- Exhibit 2. BSAS request for a procurement waiver to move the certification contract to MASH May 2, 2017. PDF.
- Exhibit 3. BSAS meeting records with MASH, October to December 2017 December 19, 2017. PDF.
- Exhibit 4. BSAS contract compliance review of MASH March 20, 2018. PDF.
- Exhibit 5. BSAS memo: Sober Housing Certification problem statement March 20, 2018. PDF.
- Exhibit 6. DPH contract amendment renewing MASH’s certification contract through fiscal 2023, with MASH’s scope of services May 29, 2018. PDF.
- Exhibit 7. MASH corrective action plan update to BSAS May 31, 2018. PDF.
- Exhibit 8. BSAS agenda for a meeting with the MASH board of directors Undated. PDF.
- Exhibit 9. MASH’s own grievance policy and procedure, as held in BSAS’s files July 26, 2021. PDF.
- Exhibit 10. BSAS corrective action plan issued to MASH February 1, 2023. PDF.
- Exhibit 11. DPH Sober Home Rental Assistance contract with MASH and the December 2024 amendment June 20, 2023. PDF.
- Exhibit 12. DPH award letter for MASH’s current certification contract June 23, 2023. PDF.
- Exhibit 13. MASH quarterly report to BSAS for July to September 2024 November 1, 2024. PDF.
- Exhibit 14. MASH executive director email to BSAS about its grievance policy and the definition of operator May 12, 2025. PDF.
- Exhibit 15. NARR grievance recommendation and MASH’s forward to BSAS May 28, 2025. PDF.
- Exhibit 16. MASH email to the operator of a Brockton home October 6, 2025. PDF.
- Exhibit 17. MASH attestation forms requiring applicants to disclaim any third-party affiliation October 10, 2025. PDF.
- Exhibit 18. MASH emails to Recovery Housing Initiative about attestation forms October 13, 2025. PDF.
- Exhibit 19. MASH decertification notice for three homes after an ownership change August 7, 2026. PDF.
- Exhibit 20. City of Greenfield notice of violation and follow-up email about a MASH-certified home November 21, 2024. PDF.
- Exhibit 21. Recovery Homes Collaborative acknowledgment of the Greenfield grievance March 17, 2025. PDF.
- Exhibit 22. City of Springfield building and planning emails about two MASH-certified homes March 20, 2025. PDF.
- Exhibit 23. Kingston Fire Department emails about a MASH-certified home March 27, 2025. PDF.
About this report
This report is published by the Vanderburgh Foundation under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. Personal contact information, resident information and anything DPH redacted have been withheld from the exhibits.120 Vanderburgh House, LLC, an organization affiliated with the Foundation, is the plaintiff in Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., Denise Menzdorf, et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, filed 10/28/2025.107
Notes
- BSAS contract award letter, June 23, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 10–11. Exhibit 12. State fact sheet, February 14, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 32.
- BSAS meeting notes, December 19, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 5. Exhibit 3. BSAS memo, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 157. Exhibit 5. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 106–108. DPH and MASH contract amendment, May 29, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 33. Exhibit 6. BSAS award letter and contract form, June 23, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 41, 46.
- City of Greenfield Notice of Violation, November 21, 2024. Exhibit 20, pp. 2–6. Kingston Fire Department emails, March 27, 2025. Exhibit 23, pp. 2–3. City of Springfield emails, March 20 and 21, 2025. Exhibit 22, pp. 2–4. MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read November 14, 2026, mashsoberhousing.org/certified-residences.
- MASH email, October 6, 2025. Exhibit 16. MASH email, October 13, 2025. Exhibit 18. MASH email, June 22, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. MASH email, September 8, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- MASH email, August 7, 2026. Exhibit 19.
- BSAS memo, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 157. Exhibit 5.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 146, 147, 154. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 106–108.
- MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 201. MASH quarterly report, March 31, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 207. MASH quarterly report, June 30, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 213. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 217. MASH quarterly report, March 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 222. MASH quarterly report, June 30, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 227. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 233. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 238. MASH quarterly report, March 31, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 244. MASH quarterly report, June 30, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 249. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), pp. 252–254. MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–65. MASH quarterly report, April 30, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 53, 55.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306. BSAS complaint review, June 6, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306, 312.
- BSAS letter, March 5, 2025. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2024-62, pp. 1–3. BSAS letter, March 21, 2025. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2024-62, pp. 1–3. BSAS letter, July 25, 2025. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2025-35, pp. 1–2.
- BSAS letter, March 5, 2025. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2024-62, pp. 1–3. BSAS letter, March 21, 2025. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2024-62, pp. 1–3.
- BSAS letter, July 25, 2025. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2025-35, pp. 1–2. DPH letter, May 22, 2026. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2025-35, p. 2.
- Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 17, § 18A(d).
- Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 17, § 18A(g).
- Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 17, § 18A(h).
- State fact sheet, February 14, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 32.
- BSAS Request for Response, November 14, 2014. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 48, 54. BSAS Request for Response, November 14, 2014. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 196, 198. Exhibit 1.
- BSAS Request for Response questions and answers, December 2014. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 137, 138. Exhibit 1.
- BSAS COMMBUYS bid record, September 24, 2015. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 45.
- BSAS memo, May 2, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 47–48. Exhibit 2.
- BSAS memo, May 2, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 47. Exhibit 2.
- MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read November 14, 2026, mashsoberhousing.org/certified-residences.
- Massachusetts HUD Recovery Housing Program draft action plan (2016 and 2020 figures). GBH News, September 18, 2017 (2017 figure). DPH, Report on Sober Homes in Massachusetts, July 2025, p. 4. (January 2025 figures). MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read November 14, 2026, mashsoberhousing.org/certified-residences.
- BSAS contract award letter, June 23, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 10–11. Exhibit 12. BSAS contract, June 20, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 76–79. Exhibit 11.
- DPH and MASH contract amendment, May 29, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 33. Exhibit 6. DPH and MASH contract budget. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 41. Exhibit 6. BSAS award letter and contract form, June 23, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 41, 46. BSAS contract award letter, June 23, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 10–11. Exhibit 12. BSAS contract, June 29, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 93. BSAS contract amendment, December 26, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract amendment), p. 1. Exhibit 11.
- BSAS contract, February 15, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 72.
- DPH sub-recipient notification, 2025. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 3–4. BSAS sub-recipient notification, December 26, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract amendment), p. 2. Exhibit 11.
- MASH Form 990 filings, fiscal years 2016 to 2025, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (EIN 81-1839101).
- DPH and RHC contract, June 30, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 63–64. Recovery Homes Collaborative subcontractor identification list, July 11, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 68.
- MASH Form 990-EZ and Form 990 returns, fiscal years 2017 to 2024, IRS copies of returns, page 1 of each (fiscal 2021 from the prior-year column of the fiscal 2022 return). Fiscal 2025: IRS e-file data as published by ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer.
- BSAS meeting notes, December 19, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 5. Exhibit 3. BSAS memo, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 157. Exhibit 5. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 106–108.
- MASH weekly report, February 27, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH report spreadsheets), p. SOBER HOUSING REPORT.
- BSAS agenda, October 1, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 16. Exhibit 3.
- MASH quarterly report, October 20, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 65.
- BSAS meeting notes, November 2, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 14. Exhibit 3.
- BSAS meeting notes, December 19, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 5. Exhibit 3.
- BSAS memo, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 157. Exhibit 5. BSAS compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), p. 110.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 147. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 147, 154. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 146. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 148. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 147–148. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 150. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 152. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 152–153. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 154. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 154–155. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 155. Exhibit 4.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 154. Exhibit 4. BSAS compliance review, March 20, 2018. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 74–75.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 156. Exhibit 4.
- MASH corrective action plan update, May 31, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 115, 121–122. Exhibit 7.
- MASH corrective action plan update, May 31, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 119. Exhibit 7.
- BSAS agenda, undated. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 219, 220. Exhibit 8.
- BSAS agenda, undated. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 219. Exhibit 8.
- DPH contract amendment, May 22, 2018. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 34–40.
- MASH weekly report, December 13, 2019. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH report spreadsheets), p. Sheet1.
- BSAS minutes, December 8, 2020. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 65. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2020. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 258.
- BSAS minutes, February 9, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 59.
- MASH web page (as produced by DPH), July 26, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 6. Exhibit 9.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 106–108. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, p. 63. Exhibit 10.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, p. 63. Exhibit 10.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), p. 107.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), p. 107. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, p. 64. Exhibit 10.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 64–65. Exhibit 10.
- MASH quarterly report, March 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 11.
- BSAS contract award letter, June 23, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 10–11. Exhibit 12. BSAS award letter and contract form, June 23, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 41, 46.
- MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–64. MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 108, 110, 111–113, 121. Exhibit 13. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), pp. 232, 237.
- MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–64.
- MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 108, 110. Exhibit 13.
- MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), pp. 232, 237.
- BSAS production index, February 14, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), pp. 1–275.
- MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 201. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 217. MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–65.
- MASH quarterly report, July 22, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 3–4. MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 108–110. Exhibit 13. MASH quarterly report, April 30, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 53, 55.
- MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 108–110. Exhibit 13.
- MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 110. Exhibit 13.
- MASH RFR response. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 24.
- MASH RFR response (Levels of Cooperative Activities). DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 15.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 149. Exhibit 4.
- Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 17, § 18A(g). BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306.
- Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, December 16, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 208. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, March 8, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, March 31, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 229. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, June 6, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 307, 312–313.
- Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, March 8, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 305–306.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 304.
- Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, June 6, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- Recovery Housing Initiative grievance to BSAS, May 25, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- NARR email, May 28, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 46–47. Exhibit 15.
- MASH email, May 28, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 46, 48. Exhibit 15.
- NARR email, May 29, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 45, 48. Exhibit 15.
- BSAS email, May 29, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 45, 48. Exhibit 15.
- MASH email, May 12, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 51. Exhibit 14.
- Grievance files on homes in Greenfield, Kingston and Springfield, March 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read November 14, 2026, mashsoberhousing.org/certified-residences.
- City of Greenfield Notice of Violation, November 21, 2024. Exhibit 20, pp. 2–3.
- City of Greenfield Notice of Violation, November 21, 2024. Exhibit 20, pp. 4–5.
- Greenfield Building Commissioner email, February 25, 2025. Exhibit 20, p. 7.
- Recovery Homes Collaborative email, March 17, 2025. Exhibit 21, p. 2. Greenfield grievance, March 15, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 305.
- MASH’s counsel letter, October 6, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read November 14, 2026, mashsoberhousing.org/certified-residences.
- Kingston Fire Department emails, March 27, 2025. Exhibit 23, pp. 2–3.
- Kingston grievance form, March 28, 2025 (screenshot of the completed form). On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read July 28, 2026 and November 14, 2026.
- City of Springfield Deputy Building Commissioner emails, March 20 and 21, 2025. Exhibit 22, pp. 3–4.
- Springfield grievance forms, March 22, 2025 (screenshots of the completed forms). On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read November 14, 2026, mashsoberhousing.org/certified-residences.
- MASH email, October 6, 2025. Exhibit 16.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302, 306. MASH letter, November 15, 2024. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- Complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, filed October 28, 2025.
- Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, December 16, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 209.
- Vanderburgh House letter, February 10, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- DPH letter, May 22, 2026. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2025-35, pp. 2–3.
- MASH email, October 13, 2025. Exhibit 18. MASH email, May 1, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. MASH email, June 22, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. MASH emails, August 5, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. MASH email, August 7, 2026. Exhibit 19. MASH email, September 8, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- DPH, Report on Sober Homes in Massachusetts, July 2025, p. 8.
- DPH, Report on Sober Homes in Massachusetts, July 2025, pp. 8, 12. The report does not mention BSAS’s 2018 compliance review or its 2018 and 2023 corrective action plans.
- DPH, Report on Sober Homes in Massachusetts, July 2025, p. 10.
- DPH, Report on Sober Homes in Massachusetts, July 2025, p. 12.
- DPH letter, May 22, 2026. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2025-35, pp. 2–3. BSAS production index, February 14, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), pp. 1–275.
- DPH letter, May 26, 2026. DPH email on request BSAS-2026-42, p. 1.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, June 6, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- Grievance files on homes in Greenfield, Kingston and Springfield, March 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
- DPH letter, May 22, 2026. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2025-35, p. 3.
Page numbers are PDF page numbers of the production or filing named. Exhibits are redacted copies published by the Vanderburgh Foundation.
Disclosure
Vanderburgh House, LLC, an organization affiliated with the Foundation, is the plaintiff in Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., Denise Menzdorf, et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, filed 10/28/2025.
