The Department of Public Health oversees the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH) through its Bureau of Substance Addiction Services (BSAS), which sets MASH’s contract duties and reviews its reports.1 BSAS records show a 2018 compliance review, corrective action plans in 2018 and 2023, and repeated report and billing problems, while DPH renewed MASH’s contract in 2018 and awarded a new one in 2023.2
- July 1, 2017MASH takes over the certification contract from the Gavin Foundation under a waiver of normal procurement rules.
- December 19, 2017BSAS tells MASH it has not filed an accurate weekly report in at least six months.
- March 20, 2018BSAS issues a contract compliance review and orders a corrective action plan.
- May and June 2018DPH renews MASH’s contract through fiscal 2023 at $210,000 a year.
- Fall 2020BSAS raises stigmatizing language about medication for addiction treatment with MASH.
- February 1, 2023BSAS issues MASH a second corrective action plan.
- June 23, 2023DPH awards MASH a new certification contract.
- July 2025DPH’s report to the Legislature on sober homes mentions neither corrective action plan.
The Oversight Tools DPH Has
MASH’s contract requires a weekly report to BSAS on certified homes, beds, pending homes, decertifications and inspections.3 It requires at least monthly meetings with BSAS and quarterly reports on trainings, certifications, technical assistance, grievances and outreach.4 It requires MASH to notify BSAS of each decision to decertify a home and the reason.5
BSAS’s own expectations set that notice at one business day.6 The state’s standard contract terms say a contractor is paid only for performance the Department accepts, and let the Department suspend or end a contract for material breach.7
2017: Six Months of Inaccurate Reports
On December 19, 2017, BSAS staff told MASH it had not submitted an accurate weekly report in at least six months.8 The same meeting notes record that MASH applied for and won a federal SAMHSA grant without telling BSAS during the application.8 MASH’s report for July to September 2017 said 33 of 52 homes due for recertification had not been recertified.9
2018: The Compliance Review and the First Corrective Action Plan
On March 20, 2018, BSAS gave MASH a written contract compliance review and an itemized list of areas where it was out of compliance.10 A BSAS memo of the same date said BSAS had met with MASH “without success over months.”11
| Problem BSAS Recorded | Source |
|---|---|
| Most certification applications lost or missing, by MASH’s own report | Exhibit 4, p. 147 |
| Homes certified and listed on the website without inspection | Exhibit 4, p. 147 |
| Facilities that were not sober homes certified, including BSAS-funded treatment programs | Exhibit 4, p. 146 |
| 23 homes overdue for recertification in one quarter, 14 by more than 30 days | Exhibit 4, p. 148 |
| Decertifications not always reported to BSAS promptly | Exhibit 4 |
| No continuing education training held for certified homes | Exhibit 4 |
| Weekly report so often wrong that RHC began a parallel report | Exhibit 4, p. 155 |
| Invoices habitually incorrect; an emergency payment needed to avoid layoffs | Exhibit 4, p. 154 |
| Helpline calls and emails about listings not answered | Exhibit 4 |
Sources12
BSAS set April 2, 2018 as the deadline for a corrective action plan.11 It wrote that if the problems were not resolved, it would bring stakeholders together to discuss whether to continue the certification process.11 MASH’s May 31, 2018 corrective action plan update promised accurate invoices, accurate weekly and quarterly reports, faster responses and professional monthly meetings.13
In May and June 2018, DPH renewed MASH’s contract through fiscal 2023 at $210,000 a year.14 An undated BSAS agenda for a later meeting with the MASH board says some corrective action items were still not done, MASH’s prior-year work plan was not executed, and MASH had billed BSAS for non-contract spending.15
2020 to 2021: Warnings About MAT and Capacity
In fall 2020, BSAS raised stigmatizing language about medication for addiction treatment (MAT) with MASH, according to BSAS’s later corrective action plan.16 In December 2020 MASH told BSAS it was struggling to recertify 183 homes a year with its staff.17 At a February 2021 meeting, attendees asked whether certification should be brought into DPH.18
2023: The Second Corrective Action Plan
On February 1, 2023, BSAS issued MASH a second corrective action plan after a grievance about a MASH Sober Housing 101 training.19 BSAS found two contract duties not performed satisfactorily: expanding the pool of NARR-trained trainers, requested in 2021 and again in 2022, and a fair and equitable grievance procedure.16 It found all three Ethics Committee members were sober home owners, contrary to MASH’s bylaws.16
It recorded that stigmatizing language and “loopholes” to deny people on MAT continued after BSAS raised them in 2020.16 It set deadlines from February 28 to April 1, 2023, and recommended adding a MAT provider to MASH’s board and Ethics Committee.20 DPH awarded MASH a new certification contract on June 23, 2023.21
2023 to 2025: Reporting Errors Continue
MASH’s quarterly reports to BSAS in this period contradict themselves in several quarters, with tables and narratives giving different counts.22 In October 2024 MASH’s executive director sent BSAS the contract expectations grid, which still carried fiscal 2018 dates, and asked whether there was an updated version.23 That grid sets quarterly reports due on the 16th of the month after a quarter ends, and MASH emailed its July to September 2024 report on November 1, 2024.24
DPH’s July 2025 report to the Legislature on sober homes describes MASH’s role but does not mention the 2018 compliance review or either corrective action plan.25 What that report says, and leaves out, is covered separately.
What Happens When the Complaint Is About MASH
BSAS reviewed three grievances about MASH from an operator affiliated with the Vanderburgh Foundation, and those reviews record no BSAS finding and no decision to the grievant.26 One review recorded that BSAS was not privy to MASH’s communications with that operator, which went through MASH’s attorney.27 The full report covers this in detail.
About This Report
This article is published by the Vanderburgh Foundation and is part of the report Certifying Sober Living: Ten Years of State Records on the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH). Vanderburgh House, LLC, an organization affiliated with the Foundation, is the plaintiff in Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., Denise Menzdorf, et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, filed 10/28/2025.28
Notes
- State fact sheet, February 14, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 32. BSAS contract scope of services, May 24, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 36. Exhibit 6.
- BSAS compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), p. 110. BSAS memo, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 157. Exhibit 5. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 106–108. BSAS agenda, undated. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 219. Exhibit 8. DPH contract amendment, May 22, 2018. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 34–40. BSAS contract award letter, June 23, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 10–11. Exhibit 12.
- BSAS contract scope of services, May 24, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 36. Exhibit 6. BSAS contract scope grid. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 132.
- BSAS contract scope of services, May 24, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 36. Exhibit 6.
- BSAS contract scope of services, May 24, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 35. Exhibit 6.
- BSAS contract expectations. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 137–138.
- Commonwealth standard contract terms. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 148.
- BSAS meeting notes, December 19, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 5. Exhibit 3.
- MASH quarterly report, October 20, 2017. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 65.
- BSAS memo, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 157. Exhibit 5. BSAS compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), p. 110.
- BSAS memo, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 157. Exhibit 5.
- BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 146, 147, 148, 150, 152, 154, 155. Exhibit 4.
- MASH corrective action plan update, May 31, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), pp. 115, 121–122. Exhibit 7.
- DPH contract amendment, May 22, 2018. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 34–40.
- BSAS agenda, undated. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 219, 220. Exhibit 8.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), p. 107.
- BSAS minutes, December 8, 2020. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 65.
- BSAS minutes, February 9, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (meeting records), p. 59.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 106–108. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, p. 63. Exhibit 10.
- BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 64–65. Exhibit 10. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), pp. 107–108.
- BSAS contract award letter, June 23, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 10–11. Exhibit 12.
- MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–64. MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 108, 110. Exhibit 13. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), pp. 232, 237.
- MASH email, October 30, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 122–132, 133.
- BSAS contract expectations. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 144. MASH email, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 114, 121, 132.
- DPH, Report on Sober Homes in Massachusetts, July 2025, p. 8.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306. BSAS complaint review, June 6, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306, 312.
- BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 305–306.
- Complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, filed October 28, 2025.
Page numbers are PDF page numbers of the production or filing named. Exhibits are redacted copies published by the Vanderburgh Foundation.
