Sober House Certification

Filing a Grievance With BSAS About MASH: What the Records Show Happens Next

The Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH) — Vanderburgh Sober Living guide graphic with Massachusetts state outline

A complaint about a certified sober home in Massachusetts goes to the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH), and a complaint about MASH goes to the Bureau of Substance Addiction Services (BSAS).1 State records show MASH logged 477 grievances in 14 reported quarters, while BSAS has no published process for deciding a grievance against MASH itself.2

What the Law Requires

M.G.L. c. 17, s. 18A requires the Department of Public Health, with BSAS, to adopt rules that include a process for receiving complaints about certified homes.3 The same subsection lets the BSAS director remove a home from the certified list when the frequency and severity of complaints show it is not maintaining standards.3 The records DPH produced to the Vanderburgh Foundation contain no such BSAS rules.4

How a Grievance About a Home Is Handled

A 2023 state fact sheet says RHC investigates grievances and MASH adjudicates grievances about certified homes.5 MASH has told the state two different things about who decides whether a grievance is substantiated: in 2023 it said RHC decides, while its written policies give that decision to its Ethics Committee.6 In 2021 MASH’s website said verbal grievances would not be acted upon, while its contract and its 2023 bid said grievances could be made by phone.7 MASH told DPH in 2023 that it keeps grievances about uncertified homes on file but does not investigate them.8

In March 2025, grievances submitted through MASH’s website form named certified homes at 28 High Street in Greenfield, 3 Smiths Lane in Kingston and 103 Euclid Avenue in Springfield. They attached letters and emails from city building and fire officials reporting fire-safety and building permit problems.9 For the Greenfield home, MASH’s grievance investigation partner wrote that it would “conduct a complete investigation,” and no outcome is on file.10 All three homes were still listed as MASH-certified on November 14, 2026. The city records are summarized in the full report.11

How Many Grievances, and With What Result

Grievances MASH reported to BSAS, by quarter, July 2021 to March 2025Bar chart. Quarterly grievance counts ranged from 16 to 55, totaling 477 across 14 reported quarters. No report was produced for October to December 2022.0204060Jul–Sep 2021: 55 grievances55Jul–Sep 2021Oct–Dec 2021: 38 grievances38Oct–Dec 2021Jan–Mar 2022: 32 grievances32Jan–Mar 2022Apr–Jun 2022: 31 grievances31Apr–Jun 2022Jul–Sep 2022: 16 grievances16Jul–Sep 2022no reportOct–Dec 2022Jan–Mar 2023: 35 grievances35Jan–Mar 2023Apr–Jun 2023: 34 grievances34Apr–Jun 2023Jul–Sep 2023: 36 grievances36Jul–Sep 2023Oct–Dec 2023: 30 grievances30Oct–Dec 2023Jan–Mar 2024: 36 grievances36Jan–Mar 2024Apr–Jun 2024: 24 grievances24Apr–Jun 2024Jul–Sep 2024: 37 grievances37Jul–Sep 2024Oct–Dec 2024: 39 grievances39Oct–Dec 2024Jan–Mar 2025: 34 grievances34Jan–Mar 2025
Grievances MASH reported to BSAS each quarter, as MASH reported them. Total for the 14 reported quarters: 477. DPH produced no MASH report for October to December 2022.12

MASH’s quarterly reports record 477 grievances across the 14 quarters from July 2021 to March 2025 for which DPH produced reports.13 The quarterly figure ranged from 16 to 55.14 In July to September 2024, MASH recorded 37 grievances: 9 substantiated, 25 not substantiated, 2 deferred, and none leading to suspension or decertification.15

That quarter, MASH handled several substantiated grievances through a conversation between the Ethics Committee chair and the operator, including one about a resident’s removal from a home.16 In October to December 2024, MASH recorded 39 grievances and none leading to suspension or decertification.17 In January to March 2025, MASH recorded 34 grievances and two suspensions over overcrowding complaints.18

Earlier Warnings About Grievance Handling

In 2018 BSAS recorded that MASH’s Ethics Committee was not producing written grievance decisions, and that 12 grievances were open on February 20, 2018.19 In 2023 BSAS found MASH’s grievance procedure was not fair and equitable, because all three Ethics Committee members were sober home owners.20

When the Grievance Is About MASH

Vanderburgh House, an operator affiliated with the Vanderburgh Foundation, filed four grievances with BSAS about MASH between December 2024 and June 2025.21 In a grievance filed in December 2024, Vanderburgh alleged that MASH paused new applications from Vanderburgh-related homes without a formal notice of any standards violation.22 In its second grievance, Vanderburgh stated that DPH had not acknowledged the first.23

In its third, Vanderburgh asked DPH to decide whether MASH should remain the state’s certifying body.24 DPH’s files hold BSAS’s internal reviews of the first three.25 Each review lists the concerns and a response drawn mostly from MASH’s executive director or MASH’s reports, and none records a BSAS finding or a decision sent to the grievant.25

One review records that BSAS was not privy to MASH’s communications about these homes, which went through MASH’s attorney.26 Vanderburgh’s fourth grievance, in June 2025, said it had received no response to the first three.27 Recovery Housing Initiative, an operator led by Shane Thomas, filed a grievance with BSAS on May 25, 2026, about how MASH handled its Lowell, Greenfield and Pittsfield applications.28

It asked BSAS to open an inquiry and review MASH’s policy of one certified home per address.28 No response to that grievance is on file.28

The National Affiliate

Operators can also take a grievance about MASH to the National Alliance for Recovery Residences (NARR), whose Massachusetts affiliate is MASH.29 On May 28, 2025, NARR recommended that MASH either set a reasonable timeframe to resume certification reviews of VSL homes or give specific evidence that those homes fail NARR standards.29 MASH forwarded NARR’s recommendation to BSAS the next day.30

About This Report

This article is published by the Vanderburgh Foundation and is part of the report Certifying Sober Living: Ten Years of State Records on the Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing (MASH). Vanderburgh House, LLC, an organization affiliated with the Foundation, is the plaintiff in Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., Denise Menzdorf, et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, filed 10/28/2025.31

Notes

  1. State fact sheet, February 14, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 32. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, December 16, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 208.
  2. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 201. MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–65. Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 17, § 18A(g). BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306.
  3. Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 17, § 18A(g).
  4. BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306. DPH letter, May 22, 2026. DPH production letter, request BSAS-2025-35, pp. 2–3.
  5. State fact sheet, February 14, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 32.
  6. MASH RFR response (Levels of Cooperative Activities). DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 15.
  7. MASH web page (as produced by DPH), July 26, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 6. Exhibit 9.
  8. MASH RFR response. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 24.
  9. City of Greenfield Notice of Violation, November 21, 2024. Exhibit 20, pp. 2–7. Kingston Fire Department emails, March 27, 2025. Exhibit 23, pp. 2–3. City of Springfield emails, March 20 and 21, 2025. Exhibit 22, pp. 2–4.
  10. Recovery Homes Collaborative email, March 17, 2025. Exhibit 21, p. 2.
  11. MASH public registry of certified homes (management.mashsoberhousing.org), read November 14, 2026, mashsoberhousing.org/certified-residences. Certifying Sober Living, “Grievances about homes that stayed certified”.
  12. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 201. MASH quarterly report, March 31, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 207. MASH quarterly report, June 30, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 213. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 217. MASH quarterly report, March 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 222. MASH quarterly report, June 30, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 227. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 233. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 238. MASH quarterly report, March 31, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 244. MASH quarterly report, June 30, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 249. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), pp. 252–254. MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–65. MASH quarterly report, April 30, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 53, 55.
  13. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 201. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 217. MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–65.
  14. MASH quarterly report, September 30, 2022. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 217. MASH quarterly report, December 31, 2021. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (MASH reports), p. 201.
  15. MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 108–110. Exhibit 13.
  16. MASH quarterly report, November 1, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 110. Exhibit 13.
  17. MASH quarterly report, January 24, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 63–65.
  18. MASH quarterly report, April 30, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 53, 55.
  19. BSAS compliance review, March 20, 2018. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, pp. 69–70. BSAS contract compliance review, March 20, 2018. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (contract and policy binder), p. 149. Exhibit 4.
  20. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. Exhibits to the complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, p. 64. Exhibit 10. BSAS corrective action plan, February 1, 2023. DPH records production, request BSAS-2024-62 (contract set), p. 107.
  21. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, December 16, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 208. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, March 8, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, March 31, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 229. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, June 6, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 307, 312–313.
  22. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, December 16, 2024. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 209.
  23. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, March 8, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
  24. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, March 31, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), p. 231.
  25. BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 302–306.
  26. BSAS complaint review. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 305–306.
  27. Vanderburgh House grievance to BSAS, June 6, 2025. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
  28. Recovery Housing Initiative grievance to BSAS, May 25, 2026. On file with the Vanderburgh Foundation.
  29. NARR email, May 28, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 46–47. Exhibit 15.
  30. BSAS email, May 29, 2025. DPH records production, request BSAS-2025-35 (emails), pp. 45, 48. Exhibit 15.
  31. Complaint, Vanderburgh House LLC v. Massachusetts Alliance for Sober Housing, Inc., et al., Suffolk Superior Court, C.A. No. 2584CV02978, filed October 28, 2025.

Page numbers are PDF page numbers of the production or filing named. Exhibits are redacted copies published by the Vanderburgh Foundation.